Recent polling data contradicts the media’s narrative suggesting President Trump has lost support among Catholic voters following his disagreements with Pope Leo XIV. Instead of a major schism, the results depict a near-even divide.
With Trump’s approval rating among Catholic voters sitting at 48% and disapproval at 52%, the numbers reflect a polarized landscape that has characterized the nation for years. Despite media predictions, this is far from a collapse.
The friction with the Vatican has been pronounced, particularly after Trump criticized Pope Leo’s remarks about war and his rhetoric towards Iran. The pope labeled Trump’s comments about annihilating Iranian civilization as “truly unacceptable.”
A new CBS poll found that 58% of weekly Mass-attending Catholics approve of President Trump’s job performance overall.
Not surprising, as these are the Catholics taking the faith seriously rather than just bearing the title.
Catholics understand that President Trump is by and… pic.twitter.com/vO1EemGyh5
— Kevin Roberts (@KevinRobertsTX) April 16, 2026
In retaliation, Trump accused the pope of being ineffective on crime and aligning too closely with leftist ideals, escalating the disagreement into a broader political and cultural battle.
The poll also indicates that Trump’s management of the conflict with Iran is a contentious issue. Only 40% of Catholic voters approve of his approach, while 60% disapprove, showing a significant divide on foreign policy.
Domestically, Trump has also faced backlash from some supporters after sharing, then removing, an AI-generated image that depicted him in a Christ-like manner.
Experts from Catholic media suggest that these events are prompting voters to reconsider their political affiliations and beliefs.
RELATED: NEW: Pope Leo’s Pro-Trump Brother Faces Bomb Threat At His Home
Jorge Enrique Mujica from Zenit.org remarked, “What emerges is not merely a decline in approval but a deeper recalibration. Catholic voters are seeking coherence between faith and political judgment, especially concerning issues of war and peace.”
Ultimately, the statistics do not indicate that Catholic voters are abandoning Trump; rather, they reflect the same national divisions affecting all demographics. The numbers reveal that while the media can shape narratives, voters are independently navigating their beliefs.
Download the FREE Trending Politics App to get the latest news FIRST >>
